How might each of these influence
each author's or historian's interpretation?
Historian A's Interpretation
*Sample Interpretation: Those
who wrote the Constitution were motivated by self-interest.
Historian B's Interpretation
*Sample Interpretation: Those
who wrote the Constitution were motivated by a desire
to promote the public good.
The author's or historian's point of view.
(Grades 4-5 and 9-12)
The evidence that the author or historian presents
to support their interpretation.
(Grades 4-5 and 9-12)
The historian's choice of questions.
(Grades 6-8 and 9-12)
The sources selected and used by the historian.
(Grades 6-8 and 9-12)
The historian's perspective.
(Grades 9-12)
The historian's beliefs.
(Grades 9-12)
*Teaching tip:
Benchmarks that are written at the level of "understanding"
(which the DSTP frequently assesses) operate on the premise
that students can apply their knowledge to new contexts. After
modeling the use of the analysis worksheet have students demonstrate
their understanding in different contexts. Synopses of other
historical debates can be found at http://www.udel.edu/dssep/tools_hist/histlist.html